Feline pawrent develops wholesome bond over 5 years with his cat who is scared of people, girlfriend doesn’t understand and forces him to choose between them: 'She should be working on earning the cat's trust and respect'

Author image for Briana Viser
Briana Viser • Writer and Editor
Oct 19, 2025 4:00 PM EDT

Pet bonds are strong. There's something about loyalty with an animal that hits differently than with a person. Even if it's your spouse, parent, or best friend, there may be something going on there that makes you think to yourself, "but…". In this story, a cat is the catalyst (no pun intended) to a relationship crashing down. The couple has been together for 6 months, so it's pretty young, and they're still building trust and comfortability. The boyfriend is the one with his cat, Mr. Whiskers, who he's had for 5 years. The boyfriend admits that Mr. Whiskers isn't the most friendly at first, and he takes a while to adjust to new people. But of course he does, he's a cat! It's one of their stereotypes, of course they hiss when they don't know someone. 

But the girlfriend takes it personally; she complains constantly about Mr. Whiskers keeping her up at night, hissing at her, and destroying her things. She gives her boyfriend an ultimatum: it's her or the cat. Well, he chooses the cat, but you'll have to read the full story for all the details. 

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to start your Caturday with the funniest felines on the internet!

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01

    my girlfriend is leaving me because of my cat

    Man and his cat
    via Raphael Angeli / Canva

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02
    This is probably gonna sound. ridiculous but I need some perspective here. My girlfriend
    via u/Augupton

  • I would absolutely choose my cat over some guy. It's so mean that she complains about this kitty instead of getting to know him! Of course he's standoffish, he doesn't know the girl! It's her job to build their trust and relationship, not a cat's. 

  • 03
    and I have been together for about 6 months and things were going pretty well until recently. The problem? My cat.
    via u/Augupton
  • 04
    I've had Mr. Whiskers for 5 years now, way before I met her. He's always been kind of particular about people and definitely took
    via u/Augupton
  • 05
    Angry girlfriend
    via Viktor Gladkov / Canva

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 06
    a while to warm up to her. She tolerated him at first but lately she's been complaining more and more. Says he's destroying her
    via u/Augupton
  • 07
    stuff, hissing at her, won't let her sleep because he meows at night. Some of it is valid but like... he's a cat?
    via u/Augupton
  • 08
    Last week she basically gave me an ultimatum. Either the cat goes or she does. I told her I can't just rehome a pet I've had for years
    via u/Augupton
  • 09
    and she lost it. Called me selfish and said if I really loved her I'd choose her over an animal. Now
    via u/Augupton
  • 10
    she's staying at her friend's place and says she's done if I don't change my mind.
    via u/Augupton
  • 11
    Cute cat
    via pixelshot / Canva

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 12
    I feel stuck. I love her but I also can't imagine just getting rid of my cat because someone else
    via u/Augupton
  • 13
    doesn't like him. Has anyone dealt with something like this before?
    via u/Augupton
  • 14
    Lst... Her ultimatum regarding the cat is a bit of a red flag. Also, you've only been together
    via u/Lstgamerwhlstpartner
  • 15
    you've only been together six months. That's not a very long time. She should be
    via u/Lstgamerwhlstpartner
  • 16
    working on earning the cats trust and respect... Not drawing lines in the sand.
    via u/Lstgamerwhlstpartner
  • 17
    SickSL Let her go. Keep the cat.
    via u/SickSL
  • 18
    meowwmixx666 if my boyfriend told me to get rid of my cat Eleanor, my dear sweet baby of two
    via u/meowwmixx666
  • 19
    years, I'd kick him to the curb so quickly. Luckily he never would, the first time he came over to meet her he
    via u/meowwmixx666
  • 20
    brought Churus for her as a surprise. Find someone patient who understands cats and won't force you into such an awful choice.
    via u/meowwmixx666
  • 21
    _Psilo_ Egocentric and manipulative. Call her bluff... but also, seriously reconsider the relationship even if she crawls back to you.
    via u/_Psilo_

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

wholesome cat animal photos adorable cats cute relationships funny cats couples Photo breakup reddit thread Reddit Cats funny animals dating
Scroll Down For The Next Article